Peter J. Kreeft. 2021. How to Destroy Western Civilization and Other Ideas from the Cultural Abyss. San Francisco: Ignatius Press.
Review by Stephen W. Hiemstra
Hardly a day passes without someone explaining sharing their views about U.S. cultural decline. This morning after my swim a woman in the net lane introduced herself and expounded at great length on why she sent her kids to a Catholic school. At noon, I heard comparisons to the Book of Judges and the Deuteronomic cycle (Deut 30:1-3). More typically, these discussions focus on bad politics and things like rampant drug use or exotic sexual practices. When I heard about Peter Kreeft’s new book on this subject, I immediately ordered a copy.
In his book, How to Destroy Western Civilization and Other Ideas from the Cultural Abyss, Peter Kreeft starts with a brilliant statement of the obvious. To save Western Civilization, start by having children (7). What is ontologically obvious is, however, not obvious to everyone—only a philosopher (or an astute student of the Bible) would be mindful of the priority of ontology.
Kreeft goes on to observe that a third of the pregnancies in North America end in abortion (8). Everyone wants to have sex, far fewer want to raise children—it is the religious people who have the most children; they are the also the happiest and live the longest (11). Thus, while the absence of children is an important indicator of cultural decline, their presence is indicator of cultural and personal advance.
Background and Organization
Peter Kreeft is a professor of philosophy at Boston College, a Catholic school. His doctorate is from Fordham University.
Kreeft must believe that cultural decline is death by a thousand cuts because he treats the subject with eighteen chapter-essays on a number of pertinent topics. These essays stand on their own without obvious connection to one another. They are:
1. How to destroy Western Civilization.
2. What can Chicken Little do?
3. The unmentionable elephant in the living room of the religious liberty debate.
4. The paradox of poverty.
5. The logic of liberalism.
6. The social, moral, and sexual effects of symbolic logic.
7. Twelve core values.
8. Traditionalism and progressivism.
9. C.S. Lewis, J.R.R. Tolkien, and the culture wars.
11. What is a liberal?
12. What is the key to a good society?
13. Seventeen freedoms.
14. Four confusions about freedom.
15. Is Agnosticism in religion the default position?
16. A word about Islam and a defense of my controversial book about it.
17. Pity vs. pacifism.
18. Judgment. (v)
The pragmatic, postmodern art is a collage so to describe and rebut problems with it, one might reasonably employ an alternative collage.
Death by a Thousand Cuts
Inherent in the observation that our cultural decline is a case of death by a thousand cuts is that small things matter. When we read in Leviticus—be holy because I am holy—we see God as concerned with details. We clearly are not. When Kreeft criticizes a thousand incoherent arguments that lay at the foundation of the postmodern era, it evokes the torture that a thinking person must endure being symbolically chained to an ant hill in the middle of such philosophical chaos. Ants possess no poisonous venom that can kill a person, yet the sum of a thousand ant bites is most certainly life-threatening. Those chained to the hill will no doubt appreciate the incineration of a few ants.
Thus, Peter Kreeft’s How to Destroy Civilization and other Ideas from the Cultural Abysis a delight to read for the reflective soul.
 The fact that Hispanics are the only ethic group in the United States where the fertility rate is above 2.1 children per woman, which is necessary for a stable population, may be related to their status as immigrants—they have had the smallest exposure to the negative factors leading to U.S. cultural decline.
Kreeft Critiques Cultural Decline
Other ways to engage online:
Author site: http://www.StephenWHiemstra.net
Publisher site: http://www.T2Pneuma.com